Thursday, April 18, 2024

Summer of chicory

Avatar photo
A chicory trial at Owl Farm in Waikato has calculated the full cost of planting the summer crop, including the cost of lost pasture from taking out paddocks.
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Owl Farm is a dairy partnership between St Peter’s School in Cambridge and Lincoln University. Last year demonstration farm manager Doug Dibley set up a trial with PGG Wrightson Seeds and Ballance Agri-Nutrients to look at the cost analysis of growing chicory.

“We’re just like any other commercial business, we need to be confident that ongoing investment in chicory will, like any farm expenditure, lend value to the Owl Farm business,” Dibley said.

He asked PGG Wrightson Seeds technical specialists Emma Bell and Charlotte Westwood to analyse costs to establish the chicory, assess probable drymatter (DM) yield from the chicory areas, and bring recommendations to the Owl Farm management committee about the ongoing use of chicory for spring 2016.

Last spring every paddock on the farm was condition-scored and seven poor-performing paddocks were ear-marked for chicory and soil tested.

Puna II and Choice chicory were direct-drilled into ground mid-October at 8kg/ha, once soil temperatures reached 12C and rising.

Despite the timely establishment of the chicory, early challenges included split strike of seed, with some seed striking early and others later. Split germination creates challenges for the timing of the herbicide application, meaning weed control can be difficult. If left too late, weeds become too advanced to be controlled, while too early can mean some smaller plants can be compromised.

By mid-December, the cows were grazing high-quality chicory paddocks as part of their daily feed allocation.

“Limited regrassing here over the years means our summer pasture quality isn’t that great,” Owl Farm manager Tom Buckley said.

“We found high-energy, high-protein chicory helpful for balancing out our poorer quality, often weed-infested pastures.”

Chicory paddocks were grazed four to five times between December and March, with cows averaging 2.2kg DM harvested/cow/grazing.

“We’d be the first to admit these chicory drymatter yields didn’t, on face value, look that great,” Dibley said.

As for any cropping, it’s reasonably straightforward to calculate costs to grow chicory, Bell said.

“Ironically 2015 chicory costs came in below budget for a range of reasons. Chemical and nitrogen fertiliser application costs were a saving as the Owl Farm team did these themselves.”

All up, the 12ha of chicory averaged costs of $666/ha, which is much cheaper than usual because no DAP was drilled with seed, something that will definitely happen next time around.

Chicory drymatter yields were calculated in two different ways. The number of grazing days for each paddock were calculated by determining the amount of chicory/cow/day eaten (energy requirements of cows less amount of pasture consumed).

The Waikato demonstration farm is using chicory to manage black beetle.

Regrassing costs can be included, above the cost of growing the chicory crop, if the chicory area is a single summer option, a six-month crop, as was the case for Owl Farm.

Chicory can be carried into a second summer if a perennial type chicory such as Puna II is used, and if chicory plant populations are greater than 25-30m2 at the end of the first summer.

“With Owl Farm, we’d always intended to regrass back into perennial pasture after the single summer,” Bell said.

Regrassing costs weren’t factored into the cost of the summer chicory areas, as Owl Farm would otherwise have simply gone grass to grass, that is, old pasture is sprayed out and straight back into new perennial pasture. This cost was assumed as a fixed cost that would have occurred with or without a summer crop.

“On that basis, regrassing cost wasn’t factored in when reviewing the Owl Farm 2015-2016 chicory costs,” she said.

The other cost of summer crops is the opportunity cost of pasture foregone. When deciding to summer crop or not, one option is to do no cropping, leaving the paddock in unimproved pasture. If the paddock is not sprayed out, even the farm’s worst paddock would continue to grow some feed. Sprayed-out crop area no longer grows pasture, creating an opportunity cost of pasture foregone. The valuation of any crop therefore needs to include the value of that pasture that the crop paddock would otherwise have grown if the crop was not established.

“It’s always been tricky to put an economic value or worth of summer pasture that is sprayed out to grow crop. Thankfully that’s been made easier in recent years with the DairyNZ Forage Value Index (FVI) putting a seasonal economic value on what pasture is worth in different parts of New Zealand throughout the year,” Westwood said.

An assumption was made that every kg DM of summer pasture foregone because of a paddock being sprayed out was worth 37c/kg DM (DairyNZ Forage Value Index Handbook) as a cost to the farm. Owl Farm paddocks were ranked using Minda Land & Feed from top to bottom drymatter yield over the previous year. The chicory paddocks worked out, on average, to yield 26% less pasture DM/ha than the balance of other Owl Farm paddocks.

By taking the average Owl Farm pasture yields between October and late March of 6324kg DM/ha, the probable amount of pasture foregone over the chicory paddocks was calculated (6324kg DM/ha less 26% = average of 4680kg DM/ha pasture foregone).

Based on the average of 9000kg DM/ha chicory yield, this lifted the true cost of chicory from 7.4c/kg DM to 22.6c/kg DM. The cost of chicory was absolutely acceptable to the Owl Farm management committee, Dibley said.

“Limited cropping or regrassing done over recent decades means we’ve got to invest in improving our pastures. At a cost of 22.6c/kg DM including opportunity cost of pasture foregone, chicory still works out cheaper than palm kernel coming onfarm, and chicory is much better quality for the cows mid-summer than palm kernel.”

The other opportunity was the break-cropping benefit chicory cropping offers, he said.

“We’ve got a major black beetle challenge here particularly on the lighter soils, and the chicory will help us out with that, rather than just going grass to grass for new pastures.”

Benefits of new, improved pasture species established into ex-chicory paddocks will continue to provide ongoing benefits for Owl Farm. Using the Pasture Renewal Charitable Trust cost benefit calculator, an additional 19,000kg DM/ha over five years will be expected from ex-chicory paddocks, averaging out at more than 3500kg DM/ha more drymatter yield each year over five years.

The final decision for Owl Farm for this coming spring was to continue with chicory.

“We identified our chicory paddocks last autumn and established Winter Star II annual tetraploid ryegrass in all but one paddock,” Dibley said.

“This gives us two goes at spraying out weeds, as well the Winter Star II growing us more pasture production through the winter. We’re looking forward to better chicory plant populations and better drymatter yield from this year’s chicory – quite exciting really.”

Total
0
Shares
People are also reading